DocsSet up sending

Deliverability

Warm-up, engaged-first sending, spam score, bounce and complaint handling, and the guards that keep your domain out of the spam folder.

Most of the work in email is staying out of the spam folder. These protections apply to every newsletter from its first send, whichever provider you use.

Warm-up

Mailbox providers are suspicious of a domain that goes from silence to thousands of emails overnight. Warm-up raises your daily volume gradually over 14 days. Turn it on under Settings → Sending → Domain warm-up; it starts at day one.

Day 1
50
Day 2
100
Day 3
200
Day 4
400
Day 5
700
Day 6
1k
Day 7
1.5k
Day 8
2k
Day 9
3k
Day 10
4.5k
Day 11
6.5k
Day 12
9k
Day 13
12.5k
Day 14
17k
  • The cap counts campaign emails per UTC day, across all campaigns of the newsletter.
  • When a campaign reaches the day's cap it pauses, then resumes on its own just after midnight UTC. Nothing is ever refused. The review step shows how a send will spread over the coming days before you press Send.
  • After day 14 no cap applies. Turning warm-up off and on again restarts at day one.
  • Switching sending provider restarts warm-up from day one too, unless you choose otherwise.

Engaged-first sending

Every campaign goes out in order of how likely each reader is to open it. Early engagement tells mailbox providers your mail is wanted, and during warm-up it means the limited daily volume goes to your best readers.

  1. Readers who opened or clicked in the last 30 days
  2. Readers who opened or clicked in the last 90 days
  3. New readers who joined in the last 30 days
  4. Readers who engaged longer ago
  5. Readers who have never opened or clicked

Only a person counts as engagement. Apple Mail's automatic opens and security scanners are ignored. See Analytics.

Deliverability checklist

Settings → Health has a checklist of the practices that matter most, each marked done or not with a link to fix it:

01Authenticate your domain (SPF, DKIM, DMARC)
02One-click unsubscribe
03Postal address in every footer
04Complaints under 0.1%
05Hard bounces under 2%
06Confirmed opt-in
07Warm-up for new domains
08Sunset inactive readers
09Clear unconfirmed sign-ups

Spam score

The review step scores each campaign the way spam filters do: SpamAssassin-style rules each add points, and the total decides the verdict. Each rule that fires is listed with its points and what to change.

Spam score bands
ScoreVerdictWhat it means
Under 2CleanNothing a filter is likely to object to.
2 to 5RiskySome filters may penalise it. Worth fixing the listed rules.
5 or moreLikely spamMany filters would junk it. Fix it before sending.

What it checks

  • Subject: empty, all capitals, repeated exclamation marks, fake RE: or FW:, money and sales phrases, lots of emoji, over 90 characters.
  • Body: common spam phrases, shouting, prices, very little text, image-only or image-heavy layouts, no preheader.
  • Links: URL shorteners, raw IP addresses, plain http, link text that shows a different domain from where it goes, too many links or domains.
  • Sender: free-mail From addresses (such as gmail.com), no-reply addresses, a From name in capitals.
  • Authentication: missing DKIM, SPF or DMARC on your domain.

Content checks

Alongside the spam score, the review step runs practical checks. They warn but never block a send:

  • Subject line present, not in capitals, not too long; a preheader is set.
  • Every merge field has a fallback, so nobody gets “Hi ,”.
  • Every image has alt text, and the email is not mostly images.
  • The email is under Gmail's 102 KB clipping limit (a warning from 85%), so the footer and unsubscribe link stay visible.
  • No link shorteners, and the first 40 links actually load.

Reputation guards

Providers suspend senders whose complaint or bounce rates climb too high. newsletter.sh watches your last 30 days and stops you well before that point:

Reputation thresholds
Rate (30 days)WarningSending blocked
Spam complaintsabove 0.05%above 0.1%
Hard bouncesabove 2.5%above 5%

A block stays until the newsletter.sh team has reviewed the newsletter with you. In practice, keeping the list clean with double opt-in and list maintenance keeps you far from either line.

Bounces and complaints

Your provider reports what happened to every email, and the platform acts on it straight away:

How feedback is handled
EventWhat happens
Hard bounceThe address is suppressed permanently. With SES it is also added to your SES account suppression list.
Soft bounceRecorded. After soft bounces from three different campaigns, the address is suppressed.
Spam complaintThe reader is suppressed immediately and never mailed again. With SES it is mirrored to your account list too.
Rejected at sendIf the provider refuses an address outright, it is suppressed as a hard bounce.

Suppression list

Each newsletter keeps its own suppression list, checked before every single send. Addresses land there after a hard bounce, a complaint, an unsubscribe, or because you added them by hand (up to 500 at a time, from Subscribers → Suppressed).

  • Only addresses you added by hand can be removed. Bounces, complaints and unsubscribes are permanent.
  • Imports and signup forms never bring back an address that bounced, complained or was suppressed by hand.

Health score

Settings → Health rolls everything into one score out of 100, with the reasons listed and a 30-day history. Healthy is 85 or more, watch is 60 to 84, and under 60 is at risk.

Health score deductions
ProblemPoints
Complaint rate above 0.1% (or from 0.05%)−40 (−20)
Hard bounce rate above 5% (or from 2%)−40 (−15)
DKIM, SPF or DMARC not passing−20 each
Delivery rate under 95%−15
Still in the SES sandbox after 14 days−10
Over 90% of the daily quota used−10
No campaign in 60 days−5

List maintenance

Dead addresses drag down every rate above. Settings → List maintenance has rules that run every night. All are off until you turn them on:

  • Delete unconfirmed sign-ups that never clicked their confirmation link after 7 days (1 to 90).
  • Sunset inactive subscribers with no open or click for 180 days (60 to 730), once they have been sent at least 3 campaigns. They are unsubscribed or tagged inactive, your choice.
  • Ask first with a re-permission email, and sunset only those who don't respond within a 14-day grace period (3 to 60).

The same page sets the default for resending to non-openers.

newsletter.sh

Newsletters on your own sending account. Invite-only, sent through Amazon SES or the provider you already use.

© 2026 newsletter.sh