DocsSend and measure

Analytics

Opens, clicks and what they really mean: Apple Mail automatic opens and security scanners are kept apart.

Email statistics are noisy. Privacy features open emails nobody read, and security scanners click links nobody chose. newsletter.sh separates those from what people actually did, so the numbers you act on mean something.

Opens

With Track opens on (in Settings → General), each email carries a tiny image, and loading it counts as an open. Reports show total opens and unique opens (one per recipient).

A reader who clicks a link or votes in a poll has clearly opened the email, so they count as one unique open even if their email app blocked images. Total opens still means image loads only.

Open rates are still labelled indicative: privacy features load images for people who never read the email (see below). Treat the open rate as a trend, and the click rate as the more reliable number.

Apple Mail automatic opens

Apple Mail Privacy Protection loads every email's images on Apple's servers when it arrives, whether or not the reader opens it. These automatic opens are recognised by Apple's proxy signature and handled differently:

  • They are included in open counts, and shown separately as automatic opens in campaign reports.
  • They never count as engagement: not for “last engaged”, engaged-first ordering, segments, welcome-series conditions, A/B results or a reader's most active hour.
  • The email.opened webhook includes "automatic": true for them.

Image proxies that only fetch when a person opens the email, such as Gmail's, count as real opens.

Clicks

With Track clicks on, links go through a short redirect that records the click and sends the reader on. The redirect only ever goes to the links saved with that email, so it can't be abused as an open redirect. Reports show clicks per link.

Scanners and bots

Corporate mail filters, link checkers and crawlers often open emails and follow every link before a person sees them. Requests from known security scanners (such as Proofpoint, Mimecast, Barracuda and Microsoft Safe Links), crawlers and scripted clients are recognised by their signature and:

  • are not counted as opens or clicks (reports show how many scanner hits were ignored),
  • never mark a reader as engaged,
  • never use up the reader's own clicks, and
  • never trigger webhooks.

For the same reason, poll votes and double opt-in confirmations need a real page visit rather than a bare link follow.

Reports

Each sent campaign has a report:

Campaign report
SectionShows
FunnelHow many were sent, delivered, engaged (opened by a person or clicked) and clicked
HighlightsClick rate, opens (with automatic opens counted apart), bounces, complaints and unsubscribes
Over timeOpens and clicks hour by hour after sending
LinksClicks for every link in the email
ReadersThe most engaged readers, recent activity and bounce reasons
PollsVotes and results for each poll, with close and reopen controls
SponsorsA shareable sponsor report link

The Analytics page covers the whole newsletter over 7, 30 or 90 days. Open and click rates there come from the issues you sent in that period, so a quiet day doesn't make them swing. It also shows emails sent and delivered, complaint and hard bounce rates, people who clicked each day, new subscribers (everyone who joined that day: signups, confirmations, imports and resubscribes) and unsubscribes.

Bounces and failed sends

  • Each email counts as delivered or bounced once, however many reports your provider sends.
  • A soft bounce that later turns permanent is counted as one hard bounce.
  • Addresses your provider refuses because they're on its own block list count as failed, not as bounces.
  • Bounces and spam reports on confirmation and test emails still remove the address, but don't count toward your newsletter's bounce and complaint rates.

Data retention

Individual open, click, delivery, bounce and complaint events are kept for 180 days, then deleted. Daily totals and campaign results are kept for as long as the newsletter exists, so reports keep working long after the raw events are gone.

newsletter.sh

Newsletters on your own sending account. Invite-only, sent through Amazon SES or the provider you already use.

© 2026 newsletter.sh